“Literacy and popular culture” - Jackie Marsh & Elaine Millard
Central issue: “(…) to make teachers more familiar with some of the literacy practices experienced by children in their homes and communities and to support teachers in using these to motivate positive learning experiences in school.” (JMEM, p.4)
> Presumption: “It is only with the development of our own awareness of the ways in which they attract and sustain interest, that we can engage our pupils more critically with the multiplicity of voices that surround them.“ (JMEM, p.7)
Observations about culture, media and literacy:
”(…) we are currently living through a period of rapid transition from a linear, print-based and page-bound culture, which developed from the introduction of the printing press, to a screen-based, hyperlinked mode of communication. Here, information is in constant flux and is only arrested for the moment of reception, when a deliberate act is made to save a semi-permanent version on disc or paper.“ (JMEM, p.5) + “It has ever been the case the each older generation feels the culture of younger people to be less demanding in content and to mark a diminution of expertise, or complexity in presentation.“ (JMEM, p.3)
» REMARK: Paradoxically, these comments are often uttered by people whom also complain frequently about ‘not being able to deal with in the immense and chaotic flood of information in the digital environment’ as well as the ‘insurmountable complexity of operating digital technology’.
»> Multiliteracies: “(…) when it comes to developing a critical literacy, reading literary works is (…) not enough, nor do they hold the only key to effective entry into the kinds of empathetic and self-actuating encounters with human experience that its advocates would have us believe.” (JMEM, p.4)
> “The electronic media are able to take children into new worlds, create new perspectives on their own and other people’s lives and allow the stories of human experience to be shaped and reshaped into ever changing messages, which are yet able to retain something of the past.” (JMEM, p.6) ***Metaphors/narratives We Live By - George Lakoff (1980)
“(…) we tentatively suggest that recognizing the social and cultural worlds of children and allowing such discourses to creep under the classroom door will encourage their literacy development in a number of important ways.” (JMEM, p.183)
1) “(…) it will provide children with the message that they do not have to cast off the identity of home and community as they enter the classroom and become consumers of a cultural universe in which they have to search for glimmers of familiar narratives.” (JMEM, p.183)
2) “(…) literature from the monolithic canon is often presented in ways which do little to locate it within the cultural worlds children inhabit. Yet children will have more interest (…) if their attention is drawn to the way in which contemporary authors draw on it in their work.” (JMEM, p.187)
» REMARK: This seems to be debatable, seeing how even adults often seem barely interested in intertextuality (layers and details of texts).
3) “(…) it can be a useful means of developing critical literacy skills. Social discourses often contain conflicting messages and children need to be able to deconstruct these texts in order to tease out the complexities. Nowhere are these dualistic discourses more clearly demonstrated than in the media.” (JMEM, p.187)
4) “[it] can provide opportunities for creating social communities in which children and teachers can engage in discourses that cement shared understanding and interests. (…) We make sense of ourselves in relation to others and popular culture presents us with opportunities to get to know those others, or at least representations of them. Therefore, when we acquire particular texts or artifacts, we are acquiring a set of social practices. (…)It provides a forum in which they can explore questions of identity and positioning in relation to others, although (…) this exploration is channeled into hegemonic discourses (…) Popular culture can also provide a meeting ground for children, a place where childhood interests overlap and form lines of communication between disparate groups and individuals.” (JMEM, p.190-191)
CHALLENGES
“The challenge for educators is to deconstruct these seemingly natural responses with children and enable them to see that there are other positions they can take within discursive practice.“ (Lowe, 1998, p.219)
PLAY
Central issue: “Because contemporary children’s play is often bound up with popular cultural icons which are unfamiliar to many adults, suspicion is cast as to its inherent value.“ (JMEM, p.45)
> “Play is embedded within socio-cultural practices and so is intimately related to popular culture. (…) The construction of play within an idealized and sanitized version of childhood ignores the fact, in reality, play is as diverse as the children (and adults) who engage in it.“ (JMEM, p.44) + “Children see themselves reading and writing in empowering contexts which may contrast with those times in the life of the nursery and classroom when literacy is associated with some level of coercion.” (JMEM, p.50)
Presumption: ”Children are constantly engaged in decoding the reality represented in the world around them, interpreting it according to their own socio-cultural practices and experiences and then encoding it, using whatever range of materials are available to them.” (JMEM, p.48) + “Play appears to function as a means of enabling children to work out things for themselves, whether that is in social, emotional, cognitive or physical domains. (…) play can provide a means for children to explore difficult issues (…).” (JMEM, p.45) + “(…) play enables children to enter realms of fantasy and desire in which they can explore issues of independence and agency.” (JMEM, p.50)
> Theoretical base:
» Characteristics according to Garvey (1977, p.10):
* pleasurable
* intrinsic motivation
* voluntary
* active engagement
» Vygotsky (1978, p.102) on play:
“(…) play creates a zone of proximal development of the child. In play a child always behaves beyond his average age, above his daily behaviour (…) play contains all developmental tendencies in a condensed form and is itself a major source of development.”
» Types of play according to Hutt et. al. (1989):
* Epistemic play: “(…) involves finding out about objects through problem-solving and investigation [which] lead[s] to cognitive development, to the acquisition of new knowledge.” (JMEM, p.47)
* Ludic play: “(…) involves playing with objects; not finding out about them, but what can be done with them; [which] may only indirectly lead to learning.” (JMEM, p.47)
» Experiencing meaning (Johnson, 1990) and experimenting with symbols (Meek, 1991) leading to ability for multimodal communication:
* Meaning: “(…) play serves as an important cognitive consolidating function by assisting in the child’s construction of meaning from experience.” (Wood & Attfield, p.24)
* Symbols: “(…) play can allow children to experiment with a range of forms for representing the world, [it] can introduce children ‘to a wide range of symbolic systems’ (Meek, p.88).“ (JMEM, p.48)
»> “Play can help to develop ‘inner speech’, a running narrative on children’s actions and thoughts.” (JMEM, p.49)
Conclusions:
“Play enables children to encode multi-modally, challenging prevailing notions of what constitutes within the usual confines of a nursery or classroom.“ (JMEM, p.48)
> “(…) literacy is not a narrowly defined set of experiences, but a broad interaction with symbols and representations (…)“(JMEM, p.48)
» “Ultimately, literacy is a social practice (Barton, 1994; Barton & Hamilton, 1998). Through literacy, we communicate with each other, cement existing discourses, shape new ones and fashion out the structure of our lives. (…) all communities use literacy, in its broadest sense, to build common structures.” (JMEM, p.191)
“[Children] transform the texts they meet through television, film, video, comics and magazines and use them to create shared social discourses which work out the concerns of childhood. Thus, children become skilled in weaving narrative tapestries using whatever glittering threads attract their attention.” (JMEM, p.60)
Source: books.google.be

